The Anxious-Avoidant Trap and How to Fix It
Written 05/02/24
Relationships between individuals with anxious attachment styles and those with avoidant attachment styles often encounter a frustrating dynamic that will harm the relationship if not addressed. However, by both partners developing more secure attachment behaviors, this cycle can be halted, allowing the relationship to thrive. Let me explain how this plays out and the path to resolving it.
The Anxious Partner's Perspective
The partner with an anxious/fearful-avoidant attachment style often grew up with some degree of childhood trauma or inconsistent parenting. This created a tendency toward hypervigilance about threats as well as negative cognitive biases where they fixate on any potential signs of distancing or rejection in the relationship. Their core need is to feel fully seen, heard, understood, and able to feel secure in their partner's commitment. Only then can they relax into trusting the relationship.
Here is how this insecurity might play out:
Wife (Anxious Partner): "I feel like you don't care about me when you spend so much time working late. "
Husband (Avoidant Partner): "I'm just trying to provide for us. Why do you always have to make everything about you?"
Notice how this response is an attempt of the partner to say they do care. However, to an anxious partner, this response will only further confirm their partner doesn't care about them as it invalidates the expressed anxiety.
The Avoidant Partner's Perspective
On the other hand, the dismissive-avoidant partner likely experienced childhood emotional neglect. As a coping mechanism, they learned to suppress deeper emotions and vulnerabilities, distracting themselves with activities that made them feel competent. Conflict and emotional closeness feel triggering, driving them into withdrawal as a protection method. Their core need is to maintain autonomy, emotional calm, and avoid subjective judgments or criticisms that make them feel defective.
Consider how this plays out:
Wife (Anxious Partner): "Why do you always seem to pull away when I try to talk about our relationship?"
Husband (Avoidant Partner): "Not this again. Can't we just have a nice evening without you bringing up problems?"
Breaking the Negative Cycle
When both partners take responsibility for insecure patterns, sharing an understanding of this dynamic, and practicing secure responding, the negative cycle can be broken.
Buildin Upon the Positive Chanes of Secure Relating. Example Conversation:
Wife (Anxious Partner): "I appreciate you making an effort to communicate more. It really helps me feel secure."
Husband (Avoidant Partner): "And I appreciate you understanding my need for space sometimes. We're getting better at this together."
It requires work, but the anxious-avoidant dynamic is very repairable when both people are willing to challenge their insecure tendencies, communicate respective needs, and meet in the middle with healthy, securely attached behaviors over time. You can do this. In session, I will work with you and your spouse to implement secure attachment behaviors with each other. This may feel a bit rigid at first but with continued practice and changed dynamics that result, you will begin to implement it outside of session and will have a changed relationship, at least up to 70% will.
The Anxious-Avoidant Cycle
When the anxious partner has a need, frustration, or complaint about the relationship, they tend to raise it with built-up anxiety and emotional desperation for feeling truly understood. This automatically activates the avoidant's tendency to feel unfairly attacked, judged, and crowded, causing them to get defensive, dismissive or shut down entirely.
This withdrawal and distancing is the anxious person's worst fear—not being seen or cared about. So they raise the issue again more adamantly and emotionally charged, fueling the avoidant's withdrawal even more as they seek emotional distance and peace. The cycle entrenches as the anxious partner feels frantic, pleading to be heard, while the avoidant feels suffocated and misunderstood.
Example Conversation:
Wife (Anxious Partner): "I just need to know that you love me and care about us. Why can't you just say that?"
Husband (Avoidant Partner): "I do love you! I dont see why you have to be so emotional! Just stop pushing."
Wife (Anxious Partner): "Your not listening to me."
Husband (Avoidant Partner): "Boy your sure needy. Why cant we just have a nice evening without you tryin to make a problem out of nothing."
Developing Secure Attachment
The path forward requires both partners to develop more securely attached behaviors.
For the Anxious Partner:
Learn to emotionally regulate.
Communicate needs calmly and respectfully.
Trust in the good intentions of their partner (knowing silence or retreat is a coping tool and doesn't mean you are not important).
Process emotions before raising issues, not in heated reactivity.
Example Conversation:
Wife (Anxious Partner): "I've been feeling a bit insecure lately. Can we plan some time together this weekend? It would really help me feel more connected."
For the Avoidant Partner:
Learn to tolerate more vulnerability and emotional intimacy.
Stay present and engaged during conflicts or heavy conversations instead of shutting down.
Self-soothe triggers around perceived attacks so you can hear your partner's perspective.
Example Conversation:
Stay Tuned, I ran out of time for thinking about this. LOL